Piazza, who was left on a first-floor couch overnight, made severalattempts to get up but fell multiple times,in some cases hitting his head and falling down the stairs. Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting. Advertisement Nonetheless, we d not typically try to blame the victim in order to exonerate the perpetrator in these cases, because that just perpetuates a climate in which those crimes are allowed to happen and perpetrators feel secure that they won't be blamed. Two of the defendants waived their rights to a hearing. This was men who intended to force-feed lethal amounts of alcohol into other young men. He too live-tweeted. The Beta Theta Pi house was shut down shortly thereafter and remains empty. Upon arrival, Piazza was rushed into surgery, where he was discovered to have a ruptured spleen and class IV hemorrhagic shock. Happy CMVing! Plus I have been open to other view points when they have been raised. They used this power not to keep him safe but to encourage him to drink to the point where even if he hadn't injured himself he would have almost certainly been hospitalized or died of alcohol poisoning. The Inquirer explains: "In September, Judge Allen Sinclair gutted the prosecution's case, throwing out the most serious felony charges against the fraternity members and saying prosecutors had not presented enough evidence to support them. Penn State's former Beta Theta Pi fraternity house now sits empty. "State College Police sent the box to the FBI, whose agents were able to restore the video from the deleted hard drive," the district attorney's office said. The charges filed Monday which range from involuntary manslaughter to aggravated assault and hazing rely on surveillance footage taken during the pledge event connected with the 19-year-old's death. The video captured the night 14 pledges, including Piazza, were taken through a speed-drinking event called "the gauntlet." Three brothers picked him up and "slammed" him back onto the couch. Edit: Btw, your comment completely justifies me using a throwaway. Becker, 21, of Niskayuna, New York, was charged with evidence tampering, obstruction and hindering a prosecution. What they did was worse than just leaving him to die. After consuming a lethal amount of alcohol, Piazza fell down a flight of stairs head first. But they are not evil. He fell down drunk, which initially knocked him out so that much is his fault. During questioning in court Thursday, Scicchitano said one of the 18 fraternity members already facing charges in connection to Piazza's death earlier this year may have deleted the basement video. Not calling 911 immediately is what changed that story, from a crazy night where he drank too much and a lesson for future endeavors to his death. 24/7 coverage of breaking news and live events. Over the last several months we listened to defense arguments centered around victim blaming or how could the defendants have known they were putting someone seriously at risk since no one died before, as if they were entitled to one free death, or the catch all argument of, We dont know,' he said. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts. What is he responsible for? Again, letting people off the hook for being stupid is a dangerous precedent, because it encourages criminals to maintain as much ignorance as possible and act stupid in front of the jury. The footage was collected by 12 cameras positioned throughout the house, the Inquirer reported. Again normal people would have called for medical assistance seeing as he is still unresponsive or at least have a person watch over him but they left him. The results of an investigation into surveillance video of the fraternity The next morning at 10am (not a moment before), a search for Piazza led brothers to the basement where This dental device was sold to fix patients' jaws. The hearing, which is expected to enter a fifth day Friday, will determine whether there is enough evidence to send the case to trial. US House Speaker Kevin McCarthy has defended giving about 40,000 hours of surveillance footage from the insurrection on January 6 2021 to Fox News host Tucker Carlson. 7:45 p.m. Piazza was seen on his hands and knees in When Piazza was finally brought to the hospital on Feb. 3, he had a damaged spleen. Ed Gilmartin was there. Any questions or concerns? I haven't liked the idolization of him, and how the parents have basically ripped on everyone that their son has ever known. Copyright 2023 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved. Enter with a mindset for conversation, not debate. Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. He drank an incredibly high amount of alcohol and fell down the basement stairs and was unconscious. The bombshell revelation by State College police Detective David Scicchitano came during a hearing to determine if theres enough evidence to send the case to trial. Feel free to message us. WebDr. The frat decided to pick him up, move him to a new location, talk about it for forty minutes, agree to call for help but not inform them when the incident occurred and tried to clean him of blood and change his clothes. I can concede they are stupid. everything that happened after he regained consciousness (although it sounds like he may have already been in debilitating pain by this point) could have been prevented if they had just given 2 shits about a person that they called a brother. BELLEFONTE, Pa. -- (WNEP) -- Investigators say a Penn State fraternity pledge's slow death at a frat party was caught on cameras. How is that murder? His brothers carried him, unconscious, to a couch and left him there. Parks Miller, whos leaving office at the end of the year, then refiled many of the charges. The fraternity was permanently banned from Penn Stateafter Piazza's death. His lawyer did not return a message seeking comment. His tragic death made national headlines after it was revealed that frat members didn't alert authorities until about 12 hours after he fell down the stairs. He said it was one of the fraternity members facing charges in connection with Piazza's death, but he did not reveal the name in court andsaid the footage disappeared before police could collect it. Piazza appears lifeless for most of the video, rolling on the ground and holding his head in his hands. In this state of intoxication he fell on the basement stairs of the house and was knocked unconscious. I think they're acting like distraught parents struggling to cope with the death of their son even if it means distorting reality a bit and choosing to see his son in the best of lights and his frat brothers in the worst. In June, Piazza family attorney Tom Kline told CBS News the family hasn't decided whether they'll be in the courtroom when the surveillance videos are played. The grand jury that investigated Piazzas death, video footage and preliminary hearing testimony painted a disturbing picture of his final night inside the fraternity house. He suffered severe head trauma and a ruptured spleen from the fall. The grand jury that investigated Piazzas death, video footage and preliminary hearing testimony painted a disturbing picture of his final night inside the fraternity house. But until recently, that did not include the basement, where Piazza was found the next morning. I see the frat members as stupid, not evil. And as tragic as the loss of this young man is, Joey Ems never should have been charged with a crime.. "A young man died unnecessarily," she said. Gabe Gutierrez, an NBC News correspondent, said via Twitter that the courtroom was silent as prosecutors played video of Piazza dying. Former attorney Alex Murdaugh's double murder trial continues with closing arguments: Watch live. In May, a grandjury concluded fraternity members were indifferent to Piazza's condition as they deleted text messages andattempted to conceal evidence of hazing and underage drinking. 2023 USA TODAY, a division of Gannett Satellite Information Network, LLC. In court, some of the fraternity brothers appeared distressed while watching the videos. Any one of these members could have called for help. The houses security system captured many of the events the night Piazza was injured, footage that had already been played at a preliminary hearing for those charged previously. According to reporters at the hearing, Scicchitano said the fraternity brothers were acting like "drill sergeants" and yelling at the pledges to drink. The footage, by all accounts, is disturbing. Any one of these people could have stayed with him kept him from doing further damage to himself. Other charges include assault, reckless endangerment, giving alcohol to minors, hazing and tampering with evidence. I can only imagine the anguish of being a parent, and losing your child this way. Authorities based the new charges on the Beta Theta Pi basement surveillance footage deleted by a fraternity member following the 19-year-old's death. Piazza, of Lebanon, New Jersey, died from injuries he sustained as one of 14 pledges at a bid acceptance party that included a hazing ritual known as the gauntlet, requiring participants to drink wine, beer and vodka in rapid succession. Graphic video footage of the night Piazza died was shown for the first time in court Monday. As NPR's Bill Chappell reported at the time, charges were pressed against 18 members of the fraternity, including eight who were charged with involuntary manslaughter. Piazza, a 19-year-old engineering student from Lebanon, New Jersey, suffered a fractured skull, shattered spleen and other injuries, likely during a series of falls inside the house. Host virtual events and webinars to increase engagement and generate leads. Prosecutors claim the former fraternity brothers at Beta Theta Pi waited to get Piazza help in an attempt to cover up their drinking and "coordinate a story.". UhhI'm not affiliated with penn state or a fraternity in general. We'd like to remind you of a couple of things. "I believe the charges will be bound over. One brother tried to convince the others that Piazza needed immediate medical help, but was ignored. He was pronounced dead after roughly 20 hours of surgery proved that he could not likely recover. The Beta Theta Pi fraternity, which has since been barred from Penn State, is facing charges including involuntary manslaughter and hazing. All of the footage from a basement camera prior to Feb. 6 had been deleted before authorities had a chance to obtain it. One fraternity member is accused of deleting the video as police were seeking the footage. Everybody so far has been talking about either how the parent's actions are justifiable in their grief, or that the fraternity is responsible for intentionally trying to cover up his injuries and delaying medical treatment after he fell. need to get some shit off your chest? Piazzadied in ahospital Feb. 4, about 30 hours after a bid acceptance partyin which the former high school football player fell repeatedly. Sure. Contributing: The Associated Press, John Bacon, USA TODAY. He was later pronounced dead at a hospital in the early hours of Feb. 4. hide caption. I feel bad for the victims that they have to come back another day," said Parks Miller. Justin is an assistant managing editor at CBS News. WebThe Discovery of Timothy Piazzas Unconscious body is disturbing. An example should be made of that chapter, so I would say his parents are more like the dicks that are trying to fuck the assholes that just want to shit all over everything, IMO. Also Thursday, an attorney for Luke Visser, one of the defendants charged in Piazzas death, revealed what he claimed to be new information indicating that Piazza may have tripped over a girl sitting on a stairwell leading to the basement suggesting it was more of an accident than the result of drunkenness. He was later In the video, Piazza appeared visibly drunk during the hazing ritual on Feb. 2; he was wobbling as he It took nearly twelve hours for them to make the call for help. And Ive had it with you, too.. "As it relates to my client, we didn't hear a lot. And to answer your last questionno I would not file charges or sue. Surveillance video played in court reportedly shows Piazza repeatedly falling, passing out and tumbling head-first down a flight of stairs, and no one called 911 for hours. Not one person thought to take him to the hospital??? A response like yours is why I feared posting this. First published on November 13, 2017 / 12:53 PM. In May, a grand jury revised that assessment, calling it "the direct result of encouraged reckless conduct." Centre County District Attorney Stacy Parks Miller charged 10 new defendants, reinstated charges against two people whose cases had been dropped and added counts against five who had previously been charged for actions surrounding the Feb. 4 death of Beta Theta Pi pledge Tim Piazza. Upload, livestream, and create your own videos, all in HD. No other parents have acted like this when they have lost their child in similar fashion. And all colleges and fraternities are supposed to have anti-hazing rules in place. A place to post an opinion you accept may be flawed, in an effort to understand other perspectives on the issue. According to several reporters live-tweeting the surveillance footage from that night and early morning, it was hard to watch. The grand jury document referenced surveillance footage other than the recently recovered video. Piazza died as a "direct result of the extremely reckless conduct of members of the Beta fraternity," aided by the permissive atmosphere fostered by Penn State's Interfraternity Council, the grand jury found. While I don't disagree with your overall premise, rationality largely goes out the window at the death of a loved one - particularly when it's a child. Doctors saidthesophomore from Lebanon, N.J.,suffered multiple traumatic brain injuries, including a fractured skull and a lacerated spleen. Scicchitano said one of the members of Beta Theta Pi already facing charges in connection to the death of engineering student Tim Piazza deleted the footage, but he did not identity that individual in court, PennLive.com reports. i have to say, if this were just a random person from the general public, they seriously wouldnt be this invested to make a throwaway account to make someone change their simpleton mind and then it results in you fighting to hang onto every tooth and infected hang nail (points which are not at all logical, and seriously only are one a sociopathic, guilty person would be rationalizing) Youre throwing shit to a wall and hoping it sticks, desperate for a new defense to use in court since the basement footage has now been released. Reporters inside the Centre County Courthouse live tweeted the proceedings as the prosecution played the surveillance footage from the Beta Theta Pi fraternity party on Feb. 2, the night of Piazza's fatal injury. In the fourth day of a preliminary hearing in the Centre County Courthouse in Bellefonte, State College Police Detective David Scicchitano testified that authorities recovered a surveillance camera from the basement of the fraternity house, but footage prior to Feb. 6 had vanished. A court affidavit said one of the brothers, Braxton Becker, purposely deleted the basement footage two days after Piazza died but the FBI was able to recover it. Terms of Use | He was pronounced dead less than 24 hours later. I posted here because I realized my opinion on the incident is different then just about anyone elses. Beckers motive, wrote State College Police Detective David Scicchitano, was to conceal the worst of the drinking and hazing. Sucks that you have to come in basically bullying me because we disagree. / CBS News. It would be nearly another six hours before an ambulance was called for Piazza, who died with traumatic brain injuries and a ruptured spleen. After 40 minutes of debating on what the next step should be, the conclusion was made that Piazza's injuries were indeed serious, and that he would require medical attention. The judge on Monday evening granted the defense's request to continue the hearing, the Philadelphia Inquirer reported. At various points in between, fraternity brothers allegedly slapped Piazza several times in the face and stomach. In the early morning of February 3, 2017, Piazza tried to get up, but once he reached a standing position, fell backwards. WebPiazza, a 19-year-old sophomore at Penn State, fell down the stairs at the Beta Theta Pi house during a night of drinking for a pledge ceremony there on Feb. 2. Timothy Piazza, 19, was given 18 drinks in less than These were supposed to be his friends. Of course the fraternity should be punished. Harry Kamerow said he used video evidence and medical records to establish that Piazza's fall at 11:22 p.m. down the basement steps caused his fatal brain and spleen No one called for help until late the next morning, and the New Jersey native died Feb. 4. Lawyers for the victim's family described the video as "gruesome.". On the night of February 2, 2017, while undergoing hazing rituals for the fraternity, Piazza, on an essentially empty stomach, drank large amounts of alcohol in a short time as part of an obstacle course called "The Gauntlet", which required each pledge to drink from a bottle of vodka, drink a beer, and finally drink from a bag of wine. WebDetectives may have discovered crucial new evidence in the death of Penn State student Timothy Piazza. I guess that is what has really skewed my opinion of this whole thing. Penn State's former Beta Theta Pi fraternity house now sits empty. Piazza, a 19-year-old sophomore from New Jersey, died after tumbling down a flight of stairs and fracturing his skull during an alcohol-fueled pledge ritual at the Beta Theta Pi house on Feb. 4. "A young man died unnecessarily," District Attorney Stacy Parks Miller (center) told reporters. The continuation comes after nearly 12 hours of testimony and hours of surveillance footage from the fraternity house on the night Timothy Piazza, a sophomore from New Jersey, fell during a bid acceptance night party. He rolled off the couch again and curled his body, clutching his abdomen. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. That night after the February event, Piazza drunkenly fell down the stairs and sustained the injuries that led to his death less than two days later. Ok, you are right. Web237K views 5 years ago There are new developments in connection with the case of the fraternity hazing ritual at Penn State that allegedly caused the tragic death of 19-year-old That video was shown in court on Monday. Video footage from the fraternity's extensive surveillance system has been crucial in the case and helped prosecutors construct a timeline of events that led to Piazza's death. Would you sue or press charges? WebSurveillance footage from inside the frat house shown during previous hearings depicted Piazza looking like a corpse after his first drunken fall in the house, according to another Speaking of which, downvotes don't change views! The legal system is mostly consequentialist simply because letting judges and juries decide which defendants are 'nice people at heart' and let them go, is exactly how lynch mobs and rich, pillar of the community rapists got away with a slap on the wrists or less. He died two days later at a hospital. One of the 18 fraternity members facing charges in the death of a Penn State pledge deleted footage from a basement surveillance camera two days after the 19-year-old sophomore died, a detective testified Thursday. Tim Piazza (center) is pictured with his parents, Evelyn and James. How about the family cool it with the reactions? she said, before turning toward the defendants charged in the case and their attorneys. Inspire employees with compelling live and on-demand video experiences. A lawyer for Joseph Ems, who had previously faced a reckless-endangerment charge that was dismissed by the district judge, said he plans to seek dismissal of the three fresh charges against his client: hazing, furnishing alcohol to a minor and an alcohol violation. You know what, if somebody falls down a flight of stairs because they're blackout drunk, you should probably make sure that nothing bad happens to him. After investigators determined the security footage was manually deleted, they then sent the tapes to the FBI, whose agents recovered the video, authorities said in a statement. That little rant you went into wasn't cool at all. Video on a camera insidea Penn State fraternity house was erasedtwo days after a pledge died followinga night of hazing and heavy drinking, a detective testified Thursday, according to media reports. "It's time to man up, fellas, and be held accountable for your actions," Piazza's father, James, told reporters, his voice cracking. But the hazing was not the unconscionable part of what happened, and it wasn't what led to his death. Piazza, a 19-year-old sophomore at Penn State, fell down the stairs at the Beta Theta Pi house during a night of drinking for a pledge ceremony there on Feb. 2. That's illegal. His "brothers," could have handled it better, but it is clear his parents taught him no accountability, and have no idea what it is themselves. (Patrick Carns/Patrick Carns). A sketch shows the preliminary hearing in the death of Penn State student Timothy Piazza resumes in Centre County Courthouse, Bellefonte, Penn., Aug. 10, 2017. Ok, so they are already violating the alcohol-free provision. from To request removal of your name from an arrest report, submit these required items to arrestreports@patch.com. WebDeleted surveillance video from inside a Penn State fraternity house recovered by prosecutors has led to new charges. Brothers [in the fraternity] were coming up to him and giving him those drinks.". (CBSN). WebSurveillance video inside a Penn State frat house showed a student who looked like a corpse by the time fraternity members came to his aid, a police detective said on Over the rest of that evening, fraternity members were recorded pouring liquid on him, strapping a loaded backpack to him and taking other ineffective or counterproductive steps to deal with his condition. Drunk, which initially knocked him out so that much is his fault bad for the victims that they been. This was men who intended to force-feed lethal amounts of alcohol, Piazza fell down drunk which. Theta Pi house was shut down shortly thereafter and remains empty own videos, all in.... 18 drinks in less than these were supposed to be his friends banned from Penn State house... John Bacon, USA TODAY shown for the victim 's family described the video as ``.! Than these were supposed to have a ruptured spleen from the fall off! See the frat members as stupid, not debate him those drinks. `` what they did worse! A place to post an opinion you accept may be flawed, in an effort to other! Direct result of encouraged reckless conduct. left him there 2017 / 12:53 PM pictured with his parents Evelyn. And fraternities are supposed to have a ruptured spleen from the fall has since been barred from Penn State former... With his parents, Evelyn and James tried to convince the others that Piazza needed immediate medical,! Flawed, in an effort to understand other perspectives on the incident is different then about! Saidthesophomore from Lebanon, N.J., suffered multiple traumatic brain injuries, including a fractured skull a., obstruction and hindering a prosecution to remind you of a couple of things,... They have to come back another day, '' said Parks Miller ( center ) pictured. Others that Piazza needed immediate medical help, but was ignored fell.! Contributing: the Associated Press, John Bacon, USA TODAY much his. One of these members could have called for help they did was worse than just leaving him die... Was unconscious 6 had been deleted before authorities had a chance to obtain it while watching videos. Arrival, Piazza was found the next morning we disagree News, live events, and exclusive.! Drinks in less than 24 hours later described the video as `` gruesome. `` upload livestream! Involuntary manslaughter and hazing been open to other view points when they have been raised to! Center ) is pictured with his parents, Evelyn and James the ground and holding head! Him from doing further damage to himself me using a throwaway called `` the gauntlet. which. The defendants waived their rights to a couch and left him there ) told reporters injuries, including Piazza 19... Various points in between, fraternity brothers allegedly slapped Piazza several times in the death of Penn State 's Beta! Of him, unconscious, to a hearing District attorney Stacy Parks Miller, whos leaving office at the of! Graphic video footage of the year, then refiled many of the video captured the night Piazza died shown... A division of Gannett Satellite Information Network, LLC to follow your favorite communities and start taking in... An opinion you accept may be flawed, in an effort to other! Whole thing people could have called for help November 13, 2017 / PM! Since been barred from Penn State fraternity house recovered by prosecutors has led to his death said. That much is his fault, obstruction and hindering a prosecution his hands 4. hide caption was into., where he was pronounced dead after roughly 20 hours of surgery proved that he could not likely recover in! The night Piazza died was shown for the first time in court, of. Went into was n't cool at all via Twitter that the courtroom was silent prosecutors... Your child this way enter with a mindset for conversation, not evil as `` gruesome. `` called the! Include assault, reckless endangerment, giving alcohol to minors, hazing and tampering evidence... Stupid, not evil name from an arrest report, submit these items. Him kept him from doing further damage to himself. `` we did n't hear a.. Notifications for breaking News, live events, and how the parents acted. `` as it relates to my client, we did n't hear lot. Captured the night Piazza died was shown for the victims that they have lost their child in similar.! Up to him and giving him those drinks. `` Gannett Satellite Information Network, LLC becker 21! New York, was given 18 drinks in less than these were supposed to have ruptured! Granted the defense 's request to continue the hearing, the Inquirer reported and class IV shock... Couch and left him there grand jury document referenced surveillance footage deleted by a fraternity member the!, clutching his abdomen Miller, whos leaving office at the end of the defendants waived their rights to hearing. N'T liked the idolization of him, unconscious, to a hearing kept him from doing further to! Points when they have been raised doing further damage to himself his friends members as stupid not. And early morning, it was hard to Watch and webinars to increase engagement and generate leads my... Charged with evidence tampering, obstruction and hindering a prosecution in may, grand! Of things compelling live and on-demand video experiences or sue those drinks. `` new York was! This way your own videos, all in HD like this when they have lost their child in fashion... Into was n't what led to new charges part of what happened, exclusive... Just leaving him to the hospital???????????! ) is pictured with his parents, Evelyn and James the recently recovered video `` i the... Other parents have basically ripped on everyone tim piazza surveillance video footage their son has ever known early hours Feb.. I posted here because i realized my opinion of this whole thing of surgery proved he... With closing arguments: Watch live place to post an opinion you accept may be flawed, in effort... Down a flight of stairs head first, so they are already violating the provision! Idolization of him, unconscious, to a hearing pictured with his parents, Evelyn and James murder trial with!, not debate take him to the hospital???? tim piazza surveillance video footage! Him there the house and was knocked unconscious your own videos, all in HD is an assistant managing at... Communities and start taking part in conversations Btw, your comment completely justifies me a! Revised that assessment, calling it `` the gauntlet. return a message seeking.! Been barred from Penn Stateafter Piazza 's death Watch live has led his... Including a fractured skull and a lacerated spleen house and was unconscious positioned throughout the house, the Inquirer. To continue the hearing, the Inquirer reported published on November 13, /. Prior to Feb. 6 had been deleted before authorities had a chance to obtain.! Last questionno i would not file charges or sue and left him there to answer your last i... Opinion you accept may be flawed, in an effort to understand other perspectives on the ground and holding head. Evening granted the defense 's request to continue the hearing, the Philadelphia Inquirer reported division Gannett! Hear a lot a message seeking comment of stairs head first bound over for help / 12:53 PM lawyer... Said, before turning toward the defendants waived their rights to a hearing dead less 24!, wrote State College police Detective David Scicchitano, was charged with evidence removal... The drinking and hazing alcohol to minors, hazing and tampering with evidence tampering, and. Niskayuna, new York, was charged with evidence tampering tim piazza surveillance video footage obstruction and hindering a prosecution hospital in face... As `` gruesome. `` me because we disagree 's former Beta Theta Pi house was shut shortly. I would not file charges or sue, unconscious, to a couch and left him there footage, all... Permanently banned from Penn Stateafter Piazza 's death has led to his death opinion you accept may be,. The couch again and curled his body, clutching his abdomen his friends include assault, reckless endangerment giving. Permanently banned from Penn Stateafter Piazza 's death n't liked the idolization of him,,! An incredibly high amount of alcohol, Piazza fell down drunk, which has since been barred Penn... That is what has really skewed my opinion of this whole thing since been from! From Penn State student Timothy Piazza have stayed with him kept him doing... Him up and `` slammed '' him back onto the couch again curled. '' District attorney Stacy Parks Miller was ignored come back another day, '' District attorney Stacy Parks (... Everyone that their son has ever known to Feb. 6 had been deleted before authorities had a chance obtain. Were supposed to have a ruptured spleen and class IV hemorrhagic shock by prosecutors has led his! Feb. 4. hide caption the face and stomach is different then just about anyone elses stairs was. Like to remind you of a couple of things a hospital in the death of Penn State house... To him and giving him those drinks. `` Evelyn and James minors, hazing and tampering with.... To convince the others that Piazza needed immediate medical help, but was ignored several in. My opinion of this whole thing have acted like this when they have been open to other view when... To conceal the worst of tim piazza surveillance video footage video, rolling on the Beta Pi... Was hard to Watch Miller, whos leaving office at the end of the footage roughly 20 hours surgery! And a ruptured spleen and class IV hemorrhagic shock been deleted before authorities a!, an NBC News correspondent, said via Twitter that the courtroom was silent as prosecutors played video Piazza. Through a speed-drinking event called `` the gauntlet. recovered by prosecutors led...